MoviePass offered unlimited movie theater tickets for $9.95 a month. The average movie ticket costs $11. You don't need an MBA to see the math problem. At its peak, MoviePass had 3 million subscribers, was losing $20 million a month, and the parent company's stock dropped 99.9%. It was the most generous deal in entertainment history — generous to everyone except the investors.
Founded
2011
HQ
New York, USA
Total Raised
$68 million
Founder
Stacy Spikes, Hamet Watt
Status
Shut down (2020)
Website
www.moviepass.comTHE ORIGIN STORY
Stacy Spikes and Hamet Watt founded MoviePass in 2011 with a simple idea: a subscription service for movie theaters, like Netflix for the cinema. The original pricing was $30-50 per month depending on your city, which was expensive but at least mathematically sustainable.
The company limped along for years, never hitting critical mass. Then in 2017, Helios and Matheson Analytics — a small data analytics firm run by Ted Farnsworth — acquired a majority stake and made the decision that would make MoviePass famous and then kill it.
WHAT THEY ACTUALLY DO
MoviePass bought full-price movie tickets on behalf of subscribers using a special debit card. When you checked into a movie on the app, MoviePass loaded the ticket price onto your card, and you bought the ticket like a normal person.
The theater got full price. MoviePass ate the difference.
At $9.95/month, they lost money on literally every subscriber who went to more than one movie per month. The theory was that MoviePass would eventually negotiate bulk discounts with theaters or make money from user data.
Neither happened.
THE PRODUCTS
The MoviePass card was a red debit card that worked at any movie theater in America. You opened the app, checked into the movie you wanted to see, and MoviePass loaded the exact ticket price onto your card within seconds.
Then you walked up to the box office or kiosk and bought the ticket normally. At its peak, the card worked at over 91% of theaters in the United States.
There was also a MoviePass Films division that invested in independent movies, hoping to profit from theatrical distribution. That also lost money.
HOW THEY GREW
The $9.95 price drop in August 2017 was the growth strategy. MoviePass went from 20,000 subscribers to 3 million in under a year.
The price was so absurdly low it went viral. Every personal finance blog, every movie lover, every deal-hunter in America signed up.
The problem was obvious: every new subscriber was a guaranteed loss. MoviePass was essentially buying growth by lighting money on fire.
The faster they grew, the faster they died.
THE HARD PART
The math. At $9.95/month and an average ticket price of $11, MoviePass lost money the moment a subscriber saw their first movie.
Heavy users — the people most attracted to the deal — were seeing 3-5 movies per month. MoviePass was paying $33-55 per month for subscribers paying $9.95.
They tried to fix this by limiting which movies you could see, adding surge pricing, and reducing the number of movies per month. Each restriction drove away subscribers.
There was no version of the business that worked at $9.95.
WHO BACKED THEM
Helios and Matheson Analytics (HMNY) acquired a majority stake in MoviePass in August 2017 and funded operations through public market stock sales. HMNY's stock went from under $3 to $38 on the MoviePass hype, then crashed to literally less than one cent.
The company raised roughly $68 million through various stock offerings, almost all of which went directly to subsidizing movie tickets. Ted Farnsworth, HMNY's CEO, insisted the data play would eventually work.
It never did.
POST-MORTEM
Why It Failed
MoviePass died from arithmetic. After the $9.95 price drop in August 2017, subscriptions exploded from 20,000 to 3 million.
Each subscriber cost the company far more than $9.95 per month. By mid-2018, MoviePass was burning through $20 million per month.
Helios and Matheson Analytics, the parent company, tried everything to stay alive. They did reverse stock splits.
They raised money through toxic stock offerings. They changed the MoviePass terms constantly — limiting films, adding surge pricing, reducing the monthly movie count from unlimited to three.
Each change drove away subscribers.
In July 2018, MoviePass literally ran out of money. The service went offline for a day because the company couldn't afford to load the debit cards.
HMNY took out an emergency $5 million loan to get the service running again. The stock, which had peaked at $38, fell below one cent.
MoviePass finally shut down in September 2019. HMNY filed for bankruptcy in January 2020.
Stacy Spikes, the original founder who had been fired, bought the brand back and attempted a relaunch in 2022, but it never regained traction.
Money Burned
$68 million
The Lesson
If every new customer costs you more than they pay you, growth isn't a strategy. It's a countdown.
Related Profiles
Head-to-Head
Compare MoviePass vs another company.